I still remember the first time I served this Grasshopper Pie at a family gathering — the room buzzed with laughter, forks clinking, and a dozen people asking for seconds. That bright, minty filling sitting on a crunchy chocolate crust feels like a small celebration in every slice. It works for holidays, potlucks, or a simple Saturday night when you want to end the day on a sweet, nostalgic note.
I’m a southern girl at heart who learned the rhythms of feeding people in a busy catering kitchen in Atlanta, and those rhythms live in every recipe I share. After 16 years of cooking professionally and raising two kids, I left the catering world to pour my energy into Recipes Vibes full time. I still cook like I’m catering for a house full of hungry friends: practical, joyful, and always with an eye for how a dish brings people together. As a mom and a wife of more than two decades, my kitchen has become a place where recipes evolve and memories get made. I love following a recipe, but I also love nudging flavors one way or another — a splash more mint, a sprinkle of toasted chocolate, or a playful swap in the crust. If you enjoy the classic charm of Grasshopper Pie but want to make it your own, you’re in the right place. I’ll walk you through a simple, no-bake version that’s forgiving and quick, plus tips I picked up while catering in Atlanta and stories from my family table that might inspire your twist. If you enjoy pie bars or whimsical hand pies, you might also like my takes on other favorites like cherry pie bars and heart-shaped hand pies, which share the same spirit of easy, crowd-pleasing desserts.
Why this recipe stands out
Grasshopper Pie stands out because it marries bold mint flavor with silky sweetness and deep chocolate crunch in a way that feels both nostalgic and fresh. This version lets the mint sing without overpowering the palate. The marshmallow fluff adds a light, airy sweetness that keeps the filling from being heavy, while the whipped cream folds in for a melt-in-your-mouth texture. I rely on these contrasting textures in my catering experience: you want something that slices cleanly, looks stunning on the plate, and disappears fast at the buffet table. This Grasshopper Pie hits all those marks.
When I catered, presentation mattered, but so did speed and simplicity. This recipe uses an Oreo crust to give you that rich chocolate base without extra fuss. It freezes quickly, making it a perfect make-ahead dessert for holidays or busy weeknights. The Creme de Menthe delivers that classic minty profile, and a little milk thins the marshmallow just enough so the whipped cream folds in smoothly, creating a dreamy lightness. For families, this pie plays well with picky eaters and adventurous kids alike; the green color feels fun and festive, but the taste stays approachable.
You’ll also love how easy it is to personalize. Add a sprinkle of chocolate shavings for a refined finish or press in chopped Andes mints for extra crunch. If you pour this into a springform for a show-stopping centerpiece or into individual tartlet shells for a party, the result feels intentional and elevated. Throughout the recipe I’ll share the small catering tricks that keep the texture perfect and the flavor balanced, so you can serve a pie that gets compliments and requests for the recipe.
How this recipe comes together
This Grasshopper Pie comes together in a few straightforward steps that I honed during my years in Atlanta catering: melt and combine the base, temper the flavor, fold in the aeration, and set. The process feels almost like magic because the marshmallow and milk combine to form a glossy, slightly fluid base that accepts the Creme de Menthe without becoming grainy. Folding in whipped cream preserves airiness and gives the filling that pillow-soft lift that makes each forkful delightful.
Start by melting the marshmallow fluff with milk gently, stirring until the mixture becomes smooth and warm but not boiling. Add the Creme de Menthe next, whisking it in so the mint integrates evenly. The trick I learned while catering is to avoid adding the liquor to the whipped cream directly — it can deflate the air. Instead, incorporate the mint into the slightly warm marshmallow mix, cool it briefly, then fold in the whipped cream in gentle strokes. That keeps the structure intact and yields a filling that slices cleanly once frozen.
Pour the filling into your prepared Oreo crust, smooth the top with an offset spatula, and into the freezer it goes. Freezing for a few hours ensures a firm slice, while leaving it in the fridge overnight gives a slightly softer set suitable for immediate serving. I often make this pie a day ahead for events; it saves time on the day of and actually slices neater after an overnight chill. If you want to speed things up for a last-minute treat, you can freeze it faster by using a shallow pan, though thin slices may thaw sooner at the table. Across the steps I’ll point out small tweaks that turn a good Grasshopper Pie into a memorable one, so you can feel confident whether you’re making it for family or guests.
Ingredients
- 1 Oreo crust
- 1 cup marshmallow fluff
- 1/2 cup Creme de Menthe
- 1/2 cup milk
- 1 cup whipped cream
Instructions
- Melt marshmallow fluff and milk in a saucepan.
- Stir in the Creme de Menthe and fold in whipped cream until combined.
- Pour the mixture into the Oreo crust and freeze until set.
Best ways to enjoy it
Grasshopper Pie tastes like a celebration, and the best ways to enjoy it depend on the occasion. For a casual family dessert, I slice it into generous wedges straight from the freezer and let it sit five minutes on the counter so the texture softens just enough to be creamy. For a dinner party, I cut neat slices, plate them with a small drizzle of chocolate sauce, and finish with a dusting of cocoa or finely chopped mint candies. If you want to make it kid-friendly, skip the liquor for a mocktail version; use peppermint extract at a lower proportion and the pie still charms little ones.
At potlucks, I bring this pie in a springform or an aluminum pan for easy transport. Because it freezes solid, it survives a bumpy ride and still slices beautifully. Grasshopper Pie pairs well with coffee, dessert wine, or a simple cup of tea. For a lighter presentation, serve mini tartlets or individual parfait glasses layered with broken Oreo, the mint filling, and a crumble topping — guests love the handheld format. When serving outdoors on warm days, keep the pie chilled in a cooler and slice only when you’re ready to serve; the contrast of cool pie against warm air feels indulgent.
If you want to plate it more formally, add a quenelle of extra whipped cream, place a small mint sprig, and grate dark chocolate over the top. That contrast of bright mint against dark chocolate looks gorgeous and tastes balanced. Also, consider adding a contrasting texture like toasted nuts or crushed peppermint bark on one side of the plate for guests who appreciate a little crunch. Throughout my catering years, those small touches elevated simple desserts into memorable finishes to a meal.
I also like to reference other simple desserts when planning a menu; if you enjoy the bar-style approach, try my cherry pie bars for a complementary option that travels well to gatherings.
How to store it properly
Storing Grasshopper Pie properly keeps the texture and flavor at their best. Because this recipe uses marshmallow fluff and whipped cream, freezing gives the most stable result. Wrap the pie tightly with plastic wrap and then a layer of foil to prevent freezer burn and to guard against absorbing other freezer scents. If you slice the pie in advance, store individual slices in airtight containers with parchment between layers so they don’t stick together. In the freezer, the pie stays great for up to two weeks. For longer storage, I recommend no more than a month to preserve the bright mint flavor.
If you prefer to keep it in the refrigerator, cover it well and expect a softer texture; it will last about 3–4 days chilled. When you slice a refrigerated Grasshopper Pie, you’ll notice it’s more delicate, so use a sharp knife warmed under hot water and wiped dry between cuts for the cleanest slices. For parties, I recommend removing the pie from the freezer 10–15 minutes before serving so it softens slightly but retains structure.
Transporting the pie to an event works best when it stays frozen and only thaws slightly before service. Carry it in a cooler with ice packs and plan to slice at the venue. If you must make it totally ahead and refrigerate, wait until one to two hours before serving so it chills through but remains creamy. These storage habits mirror what I did in catering: make ahead, protect it, and bring it out when it shines.
Emma’s Kitchen Tips
When I teach home cooks and train teams, I repeat a few simple rules: balance, temperature, and texture. For this Grasshopper Pie, balance means tasting as you go. If your Creme de Menthe packs a strong punch, start with less and add more to taste. I always recommend tasting the marshmallow-milk mixture (careful — it will be warm) before folding in whipped cream so you know the flavor level. For families with kids, swap in peppermint extract very sparingly to mimic the mint flavor without alcohol.
Temperature matters: when folding in whipped cream, ensure the marshmallow mixture has cooled slightly. If it’s too hot it will deflate the whipped cream; if it’s too cool it may stiffen and resist folding. Aim for warm to room temperature. Use a gentle folding motion with a rubber spatula, turning the bowl and cutting through the center, so you preserve air.
Texture comes from attention to the crust and the fold. Press the Oreo crust firmly into the pan so it holds the filling and slices cleanly. When chilling, avoid rapid temperature changes like moving the pie from freezer to hot sun; that can cause slight weeping. Lastly, decorate conservatively: a few chocolate shavings, a light dusting of cocoa, or a sprinkle of crushed mint candies keeps the focus on the pie’s classic flavor.
My catering secret? Make extras. Grasshopper Pie freezes well, and leftovers make perfect slices for coffee the next morning or an after-school treat for the kids.
Make it your own
I encourage you to make this Grasshopper Pie your own by experimenting with small swaps. Try a chocolate graham cracker crust if you want a slightly less sweet base, or pulse in a handful of chopped dark chocolate into the filling for a slightly more sophisticated bite. For a boozy adult version, brush a bit of Creme de Cacao on the crust before pouring the filling for extra depth. If you’re serving children, omit the Creme de Menthe and use a few drops of peppermint extract or even swap in a couple of teaspoons of mint syrup for a non-alcoholic twist.
For a festive look, fold in a handful of chopped Andes candies or sprinkle crushed candy canes on top during holidays. You can also layer the filling: pour half, chill briefly to set a bit, then add a middle layer of finely chopped chocolate or a ribbon of chocolate ganache, and finish with the remaining filling. That creates visual interest and a texture surprise that guests love. If you prefer individual portions, use a muffin tin with parchment liners and freeze for cute Grasshopper Pie bites — perfect for kids’ parties or buffet tables.
If you want to pair desserts, serve this minty pie alongside warmer flavors like a nutty biscotti or a small slice of something citrusy to contrast the mint. And if you’re curious about other handheld desserts that carry a similar nostalgic vibe, check out my heart-shaped hand pies for more playful inspiration.
Frequently asked questions
Q: Can I make this Grasshopper Pie without alcohol?
A: Yes — swap the Creme de Menthe for a non-alcoholic mint syrup or use a small amount of peppermint extract. Start with 1/4 teaspoon and increase to taste, because extracts concentrate flavor. The marshmallow and whipped cream give plenty of body, so the mint will still come through nicely.
Q: How long does Grasshopper Pie need to set?
A: For a firm slice, freeze the pie at least 3–4 hours, though overnight gives the best texture. If you chill in the refrigerator, allow at least 6–8 hours for a softer set. If you cut it too soon, the filling may be too soft and won’t slice cleanly.
Q: Can I make this in advance for a party?
A: Absolutely. This Grasshopper Pie benefits from being made a day ahead. Freeze it overnight, transport it in a cooler, and remove it 10–15 minutes before serving so it softens just enough. For multicourse events, I often make it two days ahead and keep it frozen until the day of the meal.
Q: What are good garnish ideas?
A: Chocolate shavings, a dusting of cocoa, chopped mint candies, or a few fresh mint leaves all work well. If you want a dramatic look, drizzle melted dark chocolate and let it harden before serving. Keep garnishes light so the mint-chocolate pairing remains the star.
Conclusion
If you want another classic perspective on making Grasshopper Pie or a slightly different technique, I find this Grasshopper Pie Recipe – How to Make Grasshopper Pie offers a great complementary approach that you can compare and adapt to your own tastes.
Print
Grasshopper Pie
- Total Time: 180 minutes
- Yield: 8 servings
- Diet: Vegetarian
Description
A refreshing no-bake dessert with bold mint flavor and a crunchy Oreo crust, perfect for gatherings.
Ingredients
- 1 Oreo crust
- 1 cup marshmallow fluff
- 1/2 cup Creme de Menthe
- 1/2 cup milk
- 1 cup whipped cream
Instructions
- Melt marshmallow fluff and milk in a saucepan.
- Stir in the Creme de Menthe and fold in whipped cream until combined.
- Pour the mixture into the Oreo crust and freeze until set.
Notes
For a mocktail version, substitute the Creme de Menthe with peppermint extract for a kid-friendly dessert.
- Prep Time: 15 minutes
- Cook Time: 0 minutes
- Category: Dessert
- Method: No-Bake
- Cuisine: American